What is the meaning of the mean? Let’s talk about sex

The meaning of the mean

As a professor in Statistics, reports on sexual activity provide a wide source of ideas to make proposals for students in which they have to apply statistical knowledge. Moreover, since the interpretations can be very funny and interesting, my hope is that they will never forget what they have learned.

Here is a very simple example. Consider the general question is: How many partners have you had in your life or in the last year? In surveys, the question is very clear. This means that there is no ambiguity in order to consider someone as a sexual partner or not.

Among other annual surveys, 1 reports that there are a lot of differences from one country to another, and also, from females to males (see Figure). For instance, according to these results, in 2005 the average or mean of sexual partners for men was 10,2 whereas for women it was 6,9. This is a common result; on these type of surveys, men always report more lifetime oppositesex sexual partners than women, which apparently does not surprise anyone.

The meaning of the mean

If you ask people their interpretation of this gender gap most times they refer to a different sexual behavior between males and females. No surprise.

Here the question comes. Even if there is a different behavior, is it true that men have more oppositesex sexual partners than women, in average? To understand the meaning of this mean, think in a population where there are 10 males and 10 females, with the same lifetime.

For each male (female) i = 1,…,10, denote by n(i) (m(i)) the number of differentoppositesex sexual partners (SP). Therefore, the total number of SP for males is n(1)+n(2)+…+n(10) and for females m(1)+m(2)+…+m(10). But each different SP is formed by a male and a female, so that the number of total different SPs must be the same, say N, no matter you count them by adding first across females or across males. Each new sexual partner for a man is also a new sexual partner for a woman. Therefore, the mean for females and for males should be exactly the same!

Think in the real world. In terms of the age of the population sexually active, there are no big differences between male and female distributions. The size of population is also similar. Therefore, the average estimates should be equivalent.

So, where is the difference coming from? Actually, this difference is an aim of study in academia.

One explanation is based on the belief that men overestimate and women underestimate their SPs. But, according to [2], this does not seem to be the case. In this study, participants reported number of lifetime and pastyear SPs and estimation strategies. The results show that there are no sex differences in the pastyear protocols.

On the other hand, the lifetime protocols indicated that people used different estimation strategies, and people who used the same strategy produced similar estimates. The results supports that men were more likely to use the large estimates whereas women use small ones, suggesting that “discrepant lifetime partner reports occur because men and women rely on different estimation strategies, not because they intentionally misrepresent their sexual histories” 2.

Another explanation is related with the underrepresentation of the prostitution in the surveys. This effect is studied in 3. They use data from national sex surveysand studies of prostitutes and their clients in the United States. They find that “prostitute women are underrepresented in the national surveys and that, once their undersampling and very high numbers of sexualpartners are factored in, the discrepancy disappears”.

In these surveys people were asked about the number of SP during the last year and the past five years, so the study does not consider lifetime protocols.

In summary, both results are compatible, a different estimation strategy for estimating lifetime SPs and the undersampling can explain the different statistical results. Which is definitely true is that, in average, men and women have the same number of oppositesex sexual partners.

 

References

  1. Global sex survey, Durex (2005)
  2. Brown and Sinclair (1999) Estimating number of lifetime sexual partners: Men and women do it differently, The Journal of Sex Research, 36 (3), 292-297
  3. Brewer et al (2000) Prostitution and the sex discrepancy in reported number of sexual partners, Proceedings of the National Academy of Science of the USA, 97(22) 12385–12388

1 Comment 2 Trackbacks

Leave a comment

MariaMaria

In the text it is said that the question of the survey was: How many partners have you had in your life or in the last year?
I think this question should specify “opposite-sex partners”, because you could be counting here homosexual couples…
Maybe in this text the question has been shortened…
By the way, thank you for sharing it, I’ll comment the survey with my students, it’s really interesting!

Ezjakintasunaren kartografia #45 | Dibulgazioa | Zientzia Kaiera

[…] Zer adierazi nahi du batez bestekoak? Eta emakumeen eta gizonezkoen arteko sexu-bikote kopuruei buruz ari bagara? Ba, estatistikak harrituko gaitu hainbat emaitzekin. Eva Ferreiraren artikuluan xehetasunak:  What is the meaning of the mean? Let’s talk about sex. […]

Cartografiando la ignorancia #48 - Naukas

[…] ¿Qué significa la media? ¿Y cuando nos referimos al número de parejas sexuales de varones y mujeres? La estadística tiene resultados que sorprenderán a algunos. Eva Ferreira en What is the meaning of the mean? Let’s talk about sex […]

Leave a reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>